Buybacks in Last Man Standing: When to Use Your Second Chance
Some Last Man Standing competitions allow eliminated players to buy back in for a second entry fee. It feels like an obvious decision when you have just been knocked out, but the expected value calculation is more nuanced than it appears. Here is how to think about it properly.
The KwickPicks Team has spent years running and playing Last Man Standing competitions across the Premier League, Championship, and lower leagues. We write about LMS strategy, fixture analysis, and pick advice to help players at every level survive longer — and win.
What Is a Buyback?
A buyback allows a player who has been eliminated to re-enter the competition by paying the entry fee again. The buyback entry typically starts fresh — with a full team pool available — and is treated as a new entry from the point it joins. The existing prize pot grows by the buyback fee.
Not all competitions offer buybacks, and those that do often restrict them to a specific window — for example, buybacks may only be available in the first ten rounds of a season, or limited to one per player. Check your competition's rules before assuming a buyback is available.
The Basic Expected Value Calculation
Whether a buyback is worth it comes down to one question: what is your probability of winning from this point, and does it justify the cost?
The simplest way to think about it:
Buyback is worth it if:
(Prize pot size × Your win probability) > Buyback cost
Example: £500 pot, 10 remaining players, buyback costs £10. Your win probability from a full fresh pool is roughly 1-in-11 (you vs 10 others) = 9%. Expected value: £500 × 9% = £45. The buyback costs £10. Clear positive expected value — buy back.
The calculation gets harder when the field has thinned significantly. If only three players remain and they are all experienced, your win probability as a fresh buyback entry is meaningfully lower than 1-in-4 — the remaining players have already used up some of their weaker teams, potentially giving them a stronger pool for the final rounds.
When to Buy Back
Strong case for buying back
- →You were eliminated early — before Round 10 — when the field is still large and your fresh pool is a genuine advantage
- →The prize pot is large relative to the buyback cost
- →Many players remain — giving you a realistic shot at the pot
- →You believe you made a correctable error — a genuinely bad pick, not just bad luck
Weak case for buying back
- ✕You were eliminated late in the season — only a few rounds remain and the remaining field has survived through skill
- ✕The pot is small relative to the buyback cost
- ✕Only two or three players remain — your entry is essentially halving your own winning chances at significant cost
- ✕You are buying back on emotion rather than calculation — frustration at a bad beat is not a strategy
The Fresh Pool Advantage
A buyback entry starts with a full team pool. This is a genuine strategic advantage in the early and middle rounds of a season — you have access to teams that the remaining players have already burned. If the field has used up the obvious Tier 1 picks, you still have them available.
In the later rounds, this advantage diminishes. If you buy back in Round 20 with a full pool of 20 teams, but the remaining players need to survive only four more rounds, they may have four very reliable options still available. Your full pool of 20 does not help you win four more rounds — it just gives you more choices for those same four rounds.
Buyback as Commitment to the Competition
Beyond the pure expected value, there is a social and competitive dimension to buybacks. In a private competition with friends or colleagues, buying back signals commitment to the game and keeps the field competitive. A larger field also means a larger pot — which benefits the eventual winner (who might be you, if your fresh entry outperforms).
If you enjoy the competition and can afford the buyback fee, there is a reasonable case for buying back even when the pure expected value is marginal. The entertainment value of staying in the game has its own worth. Just do not confuse that with a strategic argument.
Join a competition that offers buybacks
Browse Kwick Picks competitions to find one with buyback rules that suit your style.
Browse Competitions